Finding Peace in the Place That Broke My Heart

Reflections from My Journey, Manila, Philippines

The day before my sister’s kidney transplant, she called me from Manila. She was excited about the healthier future she hoped was waiting for her. She told me about a gift she had bought for me and could not wait to give me herself.

The next day, her husband called to say the surgery was successful. My family and I were thrilled.

A few hours later, she was gone.

Instead of returning home with the hope she had carried into that hospital, she was flown back to Israel in a gold coffin.

For years, just hearing the word “Philippines” brought anger and pain into my chest. I believed the doctors and medical team had wanted to help her, but that understanding could not ease my grief.

I wanted my sister back.

Two years ago, when my plane flew over the Philippines, I looked out at the blue ocean, the mountains, and all that green. I could see the beauty, but I could not enjoy it.

Instead, I searched for my sister somewhere below: on a mountain, near a tree, along a beach.

I knew she would not be there. Still, this was the last place she had been alive, so I looked.

It is difficult to explain that kind of searching. You know someone is gone, yet some part of you keeps looking.

When I eventually walked through the streets of Manila, I imagined her walking toward me. Had she seen this street? Had she passed this place? Somewhere in this city, she had chosen a gift for me.

I was visiting a place that was new to me while carrying a story I knew painfully well. Whatever stood before my eyes, my thoughts and heart returned to my sister.

My anger had spread beyond the hospital to a whole country and its people, including people who had nothing to do with her death. I had come to associate their home with everything I had lost.

Yet I no longer wanted resentment to shape every moment I spent there. And feel deep anger toward every Filipino.

I found myself looking for something that might reach the part of me still hurting: beauty in nature, a kind conversation, an expression of humanity.

I could not force my feelings to change, but I wanted to ease my pain.

At the Quezon Memorial, I learned a chapter of history I had never known. In the years before and during the early part of the Second World War, President Manuel L. Quezon helped open the Philippines to Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi persecution. Around 1,300 found refuge there.

As a Jewish woman, I felt deeply grateful that this country had welcomed our people when so many doors were closed. As a sister, I stood there thinking about the loss I had carried for years.

Nothing about my sister’s death had changed. But I became aware of how much of this country I had seen only through my grief.

The Philippines held more than my sorrow. It held stories of courage, compassion, and lives saved. Learning about them did not lessen what had happened to my sister, but it allowed me to see how much of my present life I was missing while carrying that anger.

As I walked through the exhibits, I felt gratitude where I had carried so much resentment. I could recognize goodness and allow it to reach me.

My love for my sister did not depend on how much anger I continued to carry. I would always miss her. But I was ready to begin releasing the blame I had attached to the place where she died.

This is the awareness and choice I write about in The Life You Choose. I could not change what had happened or decide that it would no longer hurt. But I could become aware of how my loss was shaping my present and ask whether I wanted to keep experiencing this country only through that pain.

I had wanted peace before I entered the memorial. When I encountered something that helped me see differently, I was willing to receive it.

I still wish my sister had come home and handed me that gift herself. I wish we had been given the ordinary moments she was looking forward to. Those wishes remain part of loving her.

But there was room in my heart to miss her and still be moved by the goodness around me.

I did not find my sister in the streets of Manila. But I found a moment of peace, and I allowed myself to welcome it.

Reflection question

Is there a place, memory, or part of your life you have come to see only through a painful experience? What else might you be willing to discover there, without denying what you lost?